Architectural Ingenuity : Navigating Intellectual Property in the Era of Parametric Design and Generative Algorithms

By Siddhant Jadhav

Credit : (Clark, 2012)

Introduction

In this ever-evolving landscape of architectural innovation, parametric design has burst onto the scene with a bang. Antonio Gaudí's innovative method of creating church models using hanging weights and strings foreshadowed the development of parametric design. By adjusting the weight positions, he could manipulate the shape of the catenary arches (arches resembling an upside-down U) and influence the entire model's form. This approach, akin to analog computation, involved observing the model's reflection beneath it. Gaudí wasn't alone in shaping the field of parametric design. For example, Luigi Moretti coined the term "parametric architecture," while Frei Otto's experimental "form-finding" techniques, inspired by soap films and thread paths, further solidified the movement's early foundations (Koumari, 2022).

Architects like Hadid, Gehry, Schumacher, and others have since pioneered and flourished in this sandbox. Nevertheless, their avant-garde works encountered substantial critique and even skepticism regarding the construction feasibility. Notably, the Heydar Aliyev Centre faced stringent criticism highlighting the structural intricacies and challenges stemming from its distinctive geometry (Wainwright, 2012).

In the contemporary milieu, "parametric" has become an important term in any contemporary architect’s vocabulary, showcasing their eagerness to play in the same intellectual sandbox as their masters (Mouled, 2014). As digital tools become increasingly important in shaping the tangible manifestations of their architecture, the saliency of understanding and navigating intellectual property rights has become even more paramount.

Credit : (Aliyeva, 2021)

The Rise of Parametric Design

Parametric designs would be insufficient without acknowledging its caveat on algorithmic and rule-based systems. I often catch myself perusing online repositories in search of cool Python scripts. Algorithmic designs have revolutionized how we conceptualize, ideate, and ultimately bring our visions to fruition (D'isa, 2022). These algorithms facilitate the nuanced creation of intricate and complex structures. From biomimicry in fluid forms to structures meticulously optimized for energy efficiency, parametric architecture has become emblematic of cutting-edge contemporary architectural innovation.

Generative algorithms augment parametric design, introducing automation and computational acumen. Architects utilize these algorithms to swiftly explore diverse design possibilities, accelerating the creative process and fostering groundbreaking collaboration between human ingenuity and machine intelligence in architectural solutions (Rutten, 2021) 

Watch Michael Hansmeyer's video where algorithms create intricate shapes with millions of facets. Unattainable by hand, these designs are buildable and have the potential to revolutionize architectural form perception.

Credit: (TED, 2012)

Intellectual Property Landscape

As architecture ventures into this unpredictable and exciting digital frontier, the landscape of traditional intellectual property norms may undergo a profound transformation. Conventional forms of protection, such as copyrights and patents, are being tested and redefined in the face of dynamic digital designs and algorithmic creations (Singh, 2024). The challenge lies in safeguarding innovations when attribution comes into question. Determining the owner becomes a nuanced dilemma – the architect who pioneered the algorithm, the one who fine-tuned it, or the one who ultimately deploys it? Establishing clear guidelines for attribution and ownership is crucial, ensuring that the contributions of both humans and machines are recognized.

Protecting Designs in the Digital Realm

Before proceeding, it's crucial to distinguish between software and an algorithm. An algorithm, a set of problem-solving rules, is implemented in software through programming. In the digital realm, the challenge goes beyond protecting the final design; architects must safeguard the entire generative process. Under U.S. copyright law, protection extends to original works fixed in a tangible medium, including computer programs (USPTO, 2023). However, as Local Host (2023) concludes abstract algorithms lack copyright protection.

Navigating this complex landscape requires legal strategies, encryption methods, and a keen awareness of evolving digital threats to intellectual property.

A Holistic Perspective on Architectural IP:

In the realm of architecture, plagiarism, and appropriation extend beyond replicas of iconic structures like the Las Vegas Eiffel Tower or the recreation of a European village in China. Copying and drawing inspiration from architectural maestros have been integral in advancing design, particularly in the domains of modernism, revival, and other influential styles. The scrutiny of designs from past generations remains a pivotal aspect of architectural education (Knight, 2020).

Credit: (Vkonoplev, 2017) 

Architectural functions have historically tolerated replication, but we stand at a juncture where it may be more crucial than ever, especially concerning algorithmic generations within parametric design firms (Zarei, 2012). By safeguarding the intricacies of algorithmic ownership and fostering collaboration, architects can persist in pushing boundaries. Designing for the future necessitates not only an innovative architectural function but also a strategic approach to safeguarding intellectual capital.

In conclusion, while abstract algorithms pose challenges for copyright, they may qualify under patent law if they embody novelty, a technical feature, or a process leading to invention. This safeguards the algorithm's writer's exclusive rights. Another perspective posits that standalone algorithms may lack utility; their integration into software, protectable under copyright, enhances their usability and protection.

Bibliography:

Aliyeva, X. (2021) A large building. Available at: https://unsplash.com/photos/a-large-building-with-a-very-long-curved-roof-QBHSHrRsoeQ (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

Clark, K. (2012) Adventures of KK. Available at: https://adventures-of-kk.blogspot.com/2012/05/day-8-bike-tour-gaudi.html (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

D'isa, F. (2022) THE ALGORITHM REVOLUTION IN THE ART WORLD. Available at: https://thephilosophicalsalon.com/algorithm-revolution-in-the-art-world/ (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

Knight, B. (2020) Architecture: the fine line between inspired and copied. Available at: https://www.unsw.edu.au/newsroom/news/2020/09/architecture--the-fine-line-between-inspired-and-copied (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

Koumari, L. (2022) What is Parametric Design in Architecture. Available at: https://parametric-architecture.com/what-is-parametric-design-in-architecture/ (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

Mouled, S. (2014) Parametric Design’s Influence on Today’s Architecture. Available at: https://archplanet.wordpress.com/2014/09/30/parametric-designs-influence-on-todays-architecture/ (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

ReferencesLocalhost (2023). Unraveling the Mystery: Can Algorithms Be Copyrighted and How it Affects the Tech World. [online] Available at: https://locall.host/can-an-algorithm-be-copyrighted/ [Accessed 18 Feb. 2024].

Rutten, D. (2021) The Inevitable and Utter Demise of the Entire Architectural Profession. Available at: https://discourse.mcneel.com/t/unpublished-opinion-piece/118250 (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

Singh, S. (2024) Why the need for effective IP protection in digital space is critical. Available at: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/sme-sector/why-need-for-effective-ip-protection-in-digital-space-is-critical/articleshow/106466178.cms?from=mdr (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

TED (2012) Michael Hansmeyer: Building unimaginable shapes. 27 July. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dsMCVMVTdn0 (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

USPTO (2023) Copyright basics. Available at: https://www.uspto.gov/ip-policy/copyright-policy/copyright-basics#:~:text=To%20be%20eligible%20for%20protection,or%20in%20a%20digital%20file. (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

vkonoplev, V. (2017) Children of polar explorers help fulfill the plan to green the Far North. Available at: https://unussr.d3.ru/deti-poliarnikov-pomogaiut-vypolnit-plan-po-ozeleneniiu-krainego-severa-1320021/?sorting=rating (Accessed: 2 April 2024)

Wainwright, O. (2014) Wave of protest over Zaha Hadid's Baku prizewinner. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2014/jun/30/zaha-hadid-architecture (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

Zarei, Y. (2012) The Challenges of Parametric Design in Architecture Today: Mapping the Design Practice. University of Manchester. Available at: https://parametric-architecture.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/11/The-Challenges-of-Parametric-Design-in-Architecture-Today.pdf (Accessed: 2 April 2024).

Zeiger, M. (2023). Imaginary property: artificial intelligence and design. [online] Architectural Review. Available at: https://www.architectural-review.com/essays/imaginary-property-artificial-intelligence-and-design [Accessed 18 Feb. 2024].